"You're terrible at the game of Questions," Crowley tsked. "But to satisfy your curiosity, I'm not psychic. I can't read your mind. But I do know how to read a heart. Yours doesn't beat quite right."
Other options:
no subject
"You're terrible at the game of Questions," Crowley tsked. "But to satisfy your curiosity, I'm not psychic. I can't read your mind. But I do know how to read a heart. Yours doesn't beat quite right."